The worst place we have ever stayed had a five-star view and was one hundred and forty metres from a bin collection point that operated, we established over three consecutive mornings, at ten past five.
The photographs had not mentioned this. The photographs had shown the view, which was genuine and lovely, taken from a small balcony at what must have been about seven in the evening in a month when the light was doing something flattering. Everything in the listing was true. Nothing in the listing was useful.
We think about that flat a lot, because it taught us the thing that now governs how we book anywhere: the room is almost never the problem. The room is fine. Rooms are, in the overwhelming majority of cases, fine. What goes wrong is everything around the room, and almost none of it is visible in the photographs of the room.
The neighbourhood decision, which is the only one that really matters
If you take one thing from this post: spend your effort on where, not on what.
A merely adequate room in the right part of a city will produce a better week than an excellent room in the wrong part. This is because the thing you actually do on a trip is walk out of a door in the morning, and what is on the other side of that door determines the texture of every single day.
Our test, which we apply before looking at a single property, is the breakfast radius. Can you get a coffee and something to eat within a five-minute walk, at eight in the morning, without a plan? If yes, the neighbourhood is alive and you will have a good week. If the answer requires a taxi or a fifteen-minute walk past closed shutters, no amount of rainfall shower is going to fix it.
Related, and more specific: we now avoid the immediate vicinity of the main square in any city we have not been to before. Not for snobbish reasons, but for practical ones. The square is where the noise is, where the prices are highest, and where the surrounding businesses have all been optimised for people who will be there once. Ten to fifteen minutes out, in a direction where people actually live, is almost always the sweet spot. Far enough for a bakery, close enough to walk home at midnight.
Kate’s method for finding that zone in a city she does not know: open the map, find the main sight, then look for the nearest cluster of things that are not for visitors. A primary school. A dentist. Two hairdressers. A launderette. Where there is a launderette there is a functioning neighbourhood, and where there is a functioning neighbourhood there is somewhere to have breakfast.
Hotel or apartment, decided properly rather than by habit
Most people have a default and apply it to every trip. We did for years, and it was the wrong instrument about a third of the time.
The honest breakdown, from a couple who have done a great deal of both:
Hotels win for short stays and for arrivals. Three nights or fewer, or any trip where you are landing late, and a hotel is unambiguously better. Somebody is awake. Somebody has your key. The towels exist without negotiation. There is no key-collection arrangement involving a code, a lockbox and a WhatsApp message from a person called Nikos who has not read your arrival time.
Apartments win from about five nights. The crossover point is roughly the moment you need to do laundry or would like, once, to eat breakfast without leaving. A kitchen changes the economics of a longer trip enormously, and it changes the shape of the days: you shop, which means you go to a market, which means you find out what people here actually eat.
Hotels win when you are tired or something has gone wrong. This is underrated. When your back has gone, or you have been travelling for eleven hours, or somebody is ill, a hotel is a system with staff in it and an apartment is a flat with a problem in it.
Our rough rule now: under four nights, hotel. Over six, apartment. Five nights is a coin toss and depends on whether the city has a proper market.
How to read a listing, which is a skill and not a formality
The photographs are marketing. This is not a scandal, it is simply what they are, and the correct response is to read them as marketing rather than as documentation.
Count the photographs of the bathroom. One tightly-cropped photo of a shower head means the bathroom is small or unattractive. Nobody has ever hidden a nice bathroom.
Look for the corner shot. If every photograph of the main room is taken from the same corner with a wide lens, the room is small. A genuinely spacious room gets photographed from more than one angle, because it can be.
Look out of the windows in the photographs. This is the single most useful thing on the page and almost nobody does it. What is across the street? Is it a wall? Is it a road with four lanes? In one flat we nearly booked in Seville, the window in three separate photographs looked directly onto a car park, which was not mentioned anywhere in eleven hundred words of description.
Find the floor and the lift, and do not accept a vague answer. As we have written about elsewhere, in much of Europe the “first floor” is up a substantial flight, and a great many buildings with charm have no lift at all. Charm and lifts are close to mutually exclusive.
Read the four-star reviews, not the five and not the one. The five-star ones are enthusiasm and tell you nothing. The one-star ones are usually a person having a bad life. The four-star reviews are written by people who broadly enjoyed themselves and cannot help mentioning the one thing, and the one thing is what you actually need to know. Dan has found the phrase “the only thing was” to be the most reliable eleven characters on the entire internet.
And search the reviews for the word noise. Just that word. It takes four seconds and it has saved us twice.
The things we now pay more for, having established that they are worth it
We are, as documented at some length elsewhere on this blog, not people who spend freely on accommodation. These are the exceptions we have arrived at, each of them the residue of a specific bad night.
A quiet room, explicitly requested. When booking a hotel, we now write one line asking for a room away from the lift, the road and the bar. It is free. It is granted perhaps two-thirds of the time. Two-thirds is a very good return on one sentence.
Somewhere with a person in it on the first night. See above. We will pay meaningfully more for a staffed arrival after a late flight, and we no longer feel clever about the lockbox.
A cancellable rate, on anything booked more than two months out. The premium is usually small and it buys the ability to change your mind when the shape of the trip changes, which it does. We have eaten the non-refundable rate twice and it costs more than the flexible rate would have across ten bookings.
An extra night rather than a better room. Given a fixed budget, more time in a plainer room beats less time in a nicer one, essentially always. This is the single best value judgement in travel and we hold it with some force.
The place we still talk about
For balance, because the rest of this post is a list of ways to avoid disappointment, here is the opposite.
A flat in Porto, third floor, no lift, a bathroom that could most generously be described as compact. The kitchen had two working hobs and a pan with a loose handle. The bed was fine. Nothing about the property would survive a rigorous assessment.
It had a window seat. Deep enough to sit in properly, in a wall about half a metre thick, looking down a narrow street towards a slice of the river. In the mornings the woman opposite opened her shutters at a consistent hour and had a conversation with somebody below that we never once understood and looked forward to daily.
We have stayed there four times. It is not on Dan’s return list, because the return list is for places and this is a window, but it may as well be.
Which is the caveat to everything above: all the sensible filtering in the world is a way of avoiding the bad outcome, not of producing the good one. The good one is mostly luck, and it usually turns out to be one small feature that nobody thought to photograph.
Book carefully, then hope for a window seat.
What is your non-negotiable — the quiet room, the kitchen, the person at the desk at midnight? And has anywhere unremarkable won you over with one small thing you did not book it for? Tell us in the comments. We are still, for the record, slightly bitter about the bins.
